patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Neshaminy School Board Offers New Contract Proposal; Teachers Call It An 'Insult'

Members of the Neshaminy Federation of Teachers left the barging tables only minutes after the session had begun.

 

A mere hours before talks were set to begin, the Neshaminy School Board revealed its newest contract proposal to members of the press. Board members were hopeful they could engage in meaningful talks with the district’s teachers union.

The negotiation session started at 6 p.m. Monday and just minutes later, it was over. An attorney for the teacher’s union said the proposal "insulted every teacher."

"This session was another demonstration of the board’s plan to avoid, at all costs, good faith negotiations," President of the Neshaminy Federation of Teachers [NFT] Louise Boyd said in a statement.

The NFT, which approved a strike order last month, refused to schedule additional meetings dates with the district’s negotiating team after Monday’s proposal.

The Board’s proposed contract would run from the 2011-2012 school year through the 2013-2014 school year, and not include retroactive pay for the three years the teachers have been without a contract, which meant no annual pay raises.

In the new proposal, the district’s teachers would have a 1 to 3 percent annual pay raise going forth.

Another issue the board’s proposal featured was financial contributions that teachers would have to pay for health care coverage.

Board member William O'Connor called the teacher’s current health care plan the "Rolls-Royce of Rolls-Royces."

The proposed plan would have teachers pick from three different plans that featured less of a financial strain on the district.

Teachers would have to contribute 20 percent towards the their premium cost for dental, prescription and vision insurance, according to the proposed contract.

"This [change to teacher’s health-care coverage] could save the district a couple of million dollars and up to as much as $5 or $6 million," school board President Richie Webb said.

Also laid out in the new contract proposal, the required work day would go from seven hours to eight hours a day. A teacher’s 188.5-day work year would increase by two days.

Teachers would also be contractually required to perform certain duties. The proposal stems from recent issues where contract-less teachers have skipped school events like Back-to-School Night. Many teachers also refused to write students letters of recommendation, as a sign of protest, citing they were not contractually obligated to do so.

The contract proposal featured input from community members via the Neshaminy Contract Advisory Committee. Committee members, who requested to remain anonymous, said the district should get rid of their one-time $27,500 early retirement payout. The early retirement package offered former teacher’s free insurance coverage for them, their spouse and their dependents until the age of 65, according to Webb. Board members William O’Connor added the program cost the district about $3.4 million a year and they just can’t afford that.

The proposal gets rid of the districts master's equivalency program as well. If teacher wants a pay raise due to extra schooling they would need to have a master’s degree, rather than master's equivalent.

The board members all agreed that they goal was to not to punish teachers, but help keep money going into the education of the the district’s students.

Related Topics: Contract, Neshaminy Federation of Teachers, Neshaminy School Board, and Neshaminy School District
How to do you feel about the contract dispute? Tell us in the comments.

Linda Sheridan

2:14 pm on Tuesday, July 19, 2011

I feel that any teacher who does not accept what the school board offers should go find another school district AND Ms Boyd should not have been so so so greedy
and taken the original offer made 3 years ago, which resulted in a loss for so many of the her coworkers!!!-BUT now we will pay less than that offer since the economy is worse than it was 3 years ago. We have many qualified
new teachers waiting in the wings for jobs.

Reply

Demetrios Houmas

9:56 pm on Tuesday, July 19, 2011

I just want to make sure that I understand this, The board wants to increase the amount of hours, days and duties and make them pay into their health care and not get an increase. They should not accept this!!! When will people learn you get what you pay for.

Reply
Comment_arrow

JPT

8:29 am on Thursday, July 21, 2011

Yes, welcome to the economy as it currently stands. More hours, less benefits, lower pay increases. Do you watch the news? Do you not see people losing their homes, jobs and lifetime savings? It sucks, but it's the current reality.

JPT

8:25 am on Thursday, July 21, 2011

Enough already. Settle this now. Yes, you may have to put in a few more hours...possibly even contribute to your health benefits (like most of the parents in your district), but you have well paying jobs in one of the worst economic periods in our great nation's history! Stop listening to the propaganda of your union and take a real look at the world around you. I never expected to be laid off three year ago from a good job, but the economy hit my field hard. I made it work and started my own business and, yes, I pay my own health premiums every month. I will soon have two students in your district and moved here because of Neshaminy's reputation...but I am doubting that decision now. Times are tough for everybody and you have some of the best benefits of any district in the region, including Council Rock and Central Bucks! You are the laughingstock of those districts and many around our area. So, please, for the sake of our kids, look around you, and reconsider.

Thank you!

Reply

William

9:42 am on Friday, July 22, 2011

Demetrios, before concluding the NFT should not accept the offer, do you truly understand how lucrative their contract is? For example, at the time the last contract expired in 2008 (which we honor today as part of status quo, as required by the state), our teachers were the second highest paid in salary and the highest overall in total compensation in the entire state. Yet they worked a 7 hour day when other districts in the county worked 7.5 or 8 hours.

Their benefits are like no other - an expensive, top tier health insurance plan, the premium costs of which they contribute nothing towards. And when they retire with at least 10 years of service, they get to keep those free bennies up until Medicare kicks in. They also get a free $20k life insurance policy, and free dental and eye care. If that wasn't enough, when a teacher retires in Neshaminy, they receive a one-time $27,500 bonus.

Is the NFT being asked to give up a lot? Yes, but that's only because they have a lot. This was far and away the most lucrative CBA in the state, and other district unions aspired to it. But there's a problem with the high cost to support it ... we have this thing called Act 1 that limits how much we can raise taxes. So if we cannot raise taxes beyond a certain point but still have to pay for these expensive contracts, the that leaves us with only one choice - cut student programs.

So if you expect us to keep this contract, can you please tell all of us which programs to cut?

Reply

Leave a comment